The context
The brand is an online food store, followed by the agency I work for. The campaigns run on Google and Meta, alongside automatic welcome emails, holiday campaigns and collaborations with social media creators.
The Google campaigns recorded over 1,700 online orders. But the number that decides whether the advertising makes money is another one: how much you invest to find a new customer, compared with how much that customer spends over time.
What a customer is worth
The first job was to measure customer value over time, starting from the orders. In 2024 a new customer brought in on average €75 of revenue within 30 days, €90 within 60 days and €100 within 90 days.
With this number you can decide how much to invest. An online store usually holds up when customer value is at least three times the investment needed to find them. Here it was 3.6 times at 60 days and 4 times at 90 days.
More new customers, with less investment
In 2024 the goal was precise: find more new customers while investing less for each. The number was read month by month, and in July week by week too.
| Period | Investment per new customer |
|---|---|
| Early 2024 | 31 € |
| April 2024 | 29 € |
| Q2 average | 25 € |
| June 2024 | 22.56 € |
In the quarter new customers were 345, against 236 in the first. In June alone more than 148 arrived. In July we switched off the content that performed worse on Meta and prepared the renewal of the creatives on the model of the best ones.
High order value or low order value?
Many people think a higher average order value is always better. We compared the two quarters, and here the data said the opposite. With a lower average order value the store had more people buying, more orders, more new customers at a lower investment, more revenue and more profit overall.
In July we also tried the opposite route, to measure it. In one week the average order value rose by 28%, to €52. But new customers fell, and each one required €35 of investment. It's a pattern we often see when the average order value goes up: you gain on the single order and lose on growth.
What this case teaches
1. First you measure what a customer is worth
The value at 30, 60 and 90 days tells you how much you can invest to find a new customer. Without this number, the budget is a bet.
2. A higher average order value isn't always the best choice
Here a lower average order value brought more new customers and more profit overall. You test, you measure and you decide on your own store's data.
3. The number to watch is the investment per new customer
Total orders say little. Here the investment per new customer, read every month, fell from €31 to €22.56 in six months, while new customers grew.
Frequently asked questions about food e-commerce
How much can you invest to find a new customer in a food e-commerce?
It depends on how much that customer spends over time. In this case a customer brought in €100 within 90 days, and finding one took about €25 of investment. The ratio is 4 to 1, above the 3 to 1 threshold at which an online store usually holds up.
Is it worth raising the average order value?
Not always. Here a lower average order value brought more orders, more new customers and more profit overall. When the average order value rose by 28%, new customers fell and the investment for each one rose to €35.
How do you lower the investment for each new customer?
You measure every month, switch off the content that performs worse and remake the creatives on the model of the best ones. Here, in 2024, the investment per new customer fell from €31 to €22.56 in six months.


