The context
The brand is a family-run Tuscan olive oil mill. It makes premium extra virgin oil, with hand-picked, cold-pressed olives, and also has single-variety oils. It sells directly with an Italian online store and an American one, and in the United States it already has a fast delivery system.
The olive mill handles marketing and creative choices in-house. The agency I work for takes care of the campaigns, the measurement and the contact management system.
Getting known in America
In 2026 the goal was coverage of the American market, in New York, Los Angeles and Chicago. We weren't looking for contacts or immediate sales, but for new people who would see the brand. That's why the right numbers were three: how much you invest per thousand impressions, how many different people you reach and how many times they see the ad.
We used two types of ads. Image sequences about the supply chain and the olive mill were there to reach new people, at about €1.6 per thousand impressions. The relaxing videos with the oil and the bruschetta were there to be seen again by people who had already met the brand.
In May the campaign had reached about 467,000 people in the United States, at €1.77 per thousand impressions. In total, over the years, the olive mill's campaigns have collected 13.9 million impressions.
Contacts for direct sales
Website visitors can sign up for the newsletter and get 5% off their first order. A welcome sequence starts from there. The campaigns brought in over 400 contacts for the direct sale of the oil.
A contact, however, is worth only as much as the system that follows it up. And that's where the most important work was.
The system that turns contacts into orders
In October 2026 the campaigns were stopped, and the work moved to the machine behind the sale. I ran a full check of the contact management system (the CRM) and of the tracking, and three problems came out.
- The Italian store sent neither orders nor abandoned carts to the management system. The cart reminder worked only on the American store, with 57-62% of emails opened.
- The Italian welcome was a single email, against three in the American one.
- On the American store a second tracking code was recording zero-dollar purchases, and polluting the data.
In November we rebuilt the tracking of the two stores from scratch, connected the Italian store to the contact management system and switched on the welcome and cart-reminder sequences in Italian and English. I rebuilt the Italian store's emails with a single template and identified the contacts who hadn't opened an email in twelve months, so as not to waste sends.
For Black Friday 12 scheduled emails went out, for Italian customers, English-speaking customers and American customers.
What this case teaches
1. Getting seen takes little, winning a customer takes much more
Being seen by hundreds of thousands of people in America can be done for a few euros per thousand impressions. But without a system that follows those who stopped, that visibility is lost.
2. Every campaign is judged on its own goal
A campaign built to get known is measured by the people reached, not by clicks. A sales campaign is measured by orders.
3. Tracking first, budget after
If the store doesn't send orders and carts to the management system, no automatic email can win them back. You fix the machine, then you switch the advertising back on.
Frequently asked questions about marketing for olive oil mills
How do you sell extra virgin olive oil in the United States?
You need an online store and delivery set up for the United States, campaigns that make the brand known in the right cities and an email system that follows those who sign up. In this case, coverage of New York, Los Angeles and Chicago took about €1.77 of investment per thousand impressions.
What should you measure in a brand awareness campaign?
Three numbers: how much you invest per thousand impressions, how many different people you reach and how many times they see the ad. Clicks matter little, because they aren't the goal of the campaign.
Why connect the online store to the contact management system?
Because without that connection the management system doesn't know who bought and who abandoned their cart. So the reminder emails don't go out, and the contacts collected with advertising sit idle.


