The context: growing in a shrinking market
The starting point was an Italian food group with a solid history, a name that carried weight in its segment, and a network that combined physical stores across Italy, a growing e-commerce and agreements chosen with third-party outlets. The starting numbers were good. The drive to grow was even better.
The market, however, was heading the opposite way. Inflation on food had cut purchasing power, food consumption in Italy was losing an average of 2-3% a year, large-scale retail was squeezing supplier margins. In a frame like that, growing meant taking customers from competitors, not being carried along by the current of a sector rising on its own.
The starting diagnosis brought five underlying knots into focus:
- Channels walled off from each other: physical stores, e-commerce and external partnerships worked like separate companies, with different tools, reference numbers and rules.
- No idea where customers came from: impossible to know how many of those buying in store had arrived from an online ad, and vice versa.
- Paid advertising without direction: campaigns managed channel by channel (Meta on one side, Google on the other) without an overall view of how each store was doing.
- An immature loyalty programme: the usual points card, all customers the same, no goal pushing them to come back.
- Suppliers treated as mere sellers: a relationship of pure buying and selling, no joint campaigns, no use of sales data to negotiate better.
The integrated food retail system
The first intervention (months 1-6) was substantial: building the technological and operational foundation on which growth could rest. With that foundation, every following move found its place. Without it, it would have been one patch on top of another.
The architecture of the integrated system had six components:
| Component | Function | Operating output |
|---|---|---|
| Single customer record | One valid customer profile across all channels | Customers recognised and split by behaviour |
| Automated messages | Tailored communications that go out on their own at the right moment | Sequences designed for each customer group |
| Loyalty programme engine | Loyalty programme with clear rules | Thresholds, benefits, rules for keeping your level |
| Purchase journey map | From the ad to the sale, online and in store | Return for every channel and every ad |
| Numbers dashboard | Each store's data updated in real time | Operating decisions, day by day |
| Data kept in order | Compliant privacy and clean data | A clean archive, divisible and ready to use |
The order of work was designed to deliver results from the first months, even before the foundation was finished. Each piece, as soon as it was switched on, gave strength to the next.
Knowing where customers come from, store by store
Knowing where customers come from is the hardest step in a food group with many stores. The customer sees an ad on Instagram, searches for the brand on Google that evening, visits the website two days later, and the following week walks into a store to buy. Which step do we credit?
The easy answer ("the last click before purchase") leads you astray: it punishes the channels that build awareness, over-rewards those that close the sale, sends the budget to the wrong place. We built a model that combines five different pieces of evidence:
- Tracking codes across the various channels: the online journey followed step by step, from the ad to the purchase on the site.
- Single loyalty card: every enrolled customer had their own code that followed them online and in store, joining the digital to the physical.
- Post-purchase surveys: after each purchase, a quick question, "how did you hear about us?", asked on a sample to check the figures.
- Statistical models that weigh every step: each stage of the journey valued with calculations calibrated on data from past years.
- Till data split by group: in-store purchases cross-checked with visits to the online channels in the preceding weeks.
The result was a dashboard that, for every euro of advertising, showed: how much it returned online, how much it contributed to in-store sales, and the total return of the two combined. With this clarity came choices that had been impossible before:
- 35% of the ad budget moved to the channels and ads that delivered a lot in store even if little online.
- Discovery of the "silent channels": the ones that brought no clicks but filled the stores with people, measurably.
- Budget calibrated store by store: different ad investment by area, based on how the stores were really doing.
Knowing where customers come from is a strategy choice, even before it is a number. It changes where you put the money, what you look at, who you reward inside the company. When you don't know this, every euro of marketing becomes a blind gamble. Matteo Coloru
Paid advertising run store by store
Running paid advertising in a food group with many stores is complex work. Every store has its own catchment area, its own strong season, its own local events, its own starting point. Managing everything from the centre, without calibrating store by store, means throwing away 30-50% of ad investment.
The system in this case worked on three levels:
Level 1, the budget split (every month)
Every month, the marketing team reviewed how to split the budget between: building brand awareness across the country, bringing customers into individual stores, re-engaging those who had already shown interest, bringing loyal customers back. The proportions changed according to the quarter's goals and the results of the previous months.
Level 2, store-by-store fine-tuning (every week)
Every week, each store was judged on four numbers: footfall, average basket, how often customers came back, how many promotions hit their target. The budget moved towards the stores with the most room to grow and the ads were tailored to the area.
Level 3, the day's corrections (every day)
Every day, the system (partly automatic with rules, partly with a person checking) corrected bids and budgets on the go, based on weather, local events, hour-by-hour trends. Example: a surprise rain at the weekend moved money to home delivery and took it away from the physical store.
The leverage effect was strong: same total budget, +47% marketing return in 18 months. In plain terms, every euro invested returned almost twice as much as before.
Tiered loyalty programme: the engine of repeat purchases
The tiered loyalty programme took the place of the usual points card, which moved very little and served no strategic purpose. The new programme had three levels with clear rules:
| Level | Threshold to stay | Main benefits | Share of customers |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bronze | Free to join | Standard discounts, newsletter | 72% |
| Silver | Mid spend threshold | Dedicated discounts, previews, events | 21% |
| Gold | High spend threshold | Top benefits, dedicated support, surprises | 7% |
Four operating principles that made the difference:
- Clear thresholds, with a goal ahead: every customer knew exactly what to do to move up a level. A goal moves people more than points do.
- Benefits to experience, beyond the discount: gold members received previews, private events, tailor-made surprises. A sense of privilege beats a discount percentage.
- Clear rules for keeping your level: to stay gold you had to hold a spend threshold each year. No eternal levels that empty the programme of meaning.
- Attention to those about to leave: gold customers who showed signs of drifting away received a dedicated contact before disappearing altogether.
Operational lesson
A well-built tiered loyalty programme turns the usual points card (passive, the same for everyone, moving little) into a tool that splits customers by value and treats them accordingly. It recognises those who are worth the most, gives a goal to those in the middle, wins back those about to leave. From an overhead to a growth lever.
Supply chain and suppliers as a strategic resource
In food retail, the relationship with suppliers is usually pure buying and selling: you negotiate the price, you buy the volumes, and that's it. That leaves huge opportunities on the table. A store that brings tidy sales data and knows how to do marketing is an ally to the supplier, not one customer among many.
We rebuilt the relationship with the group's 30 main suppliers on four pillars:
- Sales data shared product by product: monthly reports with sales figures, shelf space, how promotions performed. Total transparency as currency.
- Marketing paid half and half: campaigns on the supplier's products, with the outlay split 50/50. Both win: the supplier moves more of its products, the group lowers its marketing outlay per category.
- Territory exclusive on premium lines: for the flagship products, exclusive agreements of 6-12 months that raised margin and gave something competitors didn't have.
- Suppliers' products in the top loyalty tier: gold customers received previews of partner suppliers' products, creating a desire effect on both brands together.
The Sole 24 Ore certified results
Il Sole 24 Ore Leader della Crescita is one of the most serious recognitions in the Italian business landscape. The method measures how much revenue grew on average each year over three years, checking the balance-sheet data directly. The award is won on certified numbers, never on an application made of words.
The group in this case came 1st in the food category in Italy, 3rd among the Rising Stars and 4th in the overall ranking, with a compound annual growth rate of 218.94% (revenue ×32 in three years). It is an extraordinary result, especially when you consider three things:
- The market: a food sector shrinking by an average of 2-3% a year over the same period.
- The starting point: not a small company at the beginning, but an already solid group.
- Solidity: growth with margin and with the cash in order, not by burning money.
The key operating metrics of the period:
| Metric | Three-year performance |
|---|---|
| Compound annual growth rate (CAGR) | +218.94% · revenue ×32 in 3 years |
| Share of revenue from the loyalty programme | 47% |
| How often loyal customers buy | 4.3× compared with the rest |
| Return on paid advertising | +47% at the same budget |
| Marketing paid for by suppliers in one year | 240,000 € |
| Sole 24 Ore award 2026 | 1st in food · 3rd Rising Stars · 4th overall |
Lessons for growing food groups
1. The integrated system as the foundation
A customer recognised on every channel is the starting condition. Without it, every marketing move becomes a patch. Putting money into a single customer record, automated messages and data in order is the most important choice of the first 12 months of growth.
2. Knowing where customers come from is strategy
Knowing where customers come from is a strategy choice, before it is a report: it changes where you put the money, what you look at, who you reward. When you don't know, every decision on how to split the budget becomes a gamble.
3. Advertising run store by store
Advertising managed entirely from the centre, without calibrating store by store, throws away 30-50% of ad investment. Run on three levels (the monthly split, the weekly fine-tuning, the day's corrections) it returns 40-50% more at the same budget.
4. A tiered loyalty programme, not a points one
The usual points card moves little and serves no strategic purpose. The tiered programme (bronze/silver/gold with benefits to experience) splits customers by value and gives them a goal that brings them back.
5. Suppliers as allies
Sharing sales data with your main suppliers turns a simple purchase into an alliance. Extra discounts, jointly paid marketing, territory exclusives, products inside the loyalty programme. Data is the currency of today's retail.
Frequently asked questions about multi-store food retail
What is the Sole 24 Ore Leader della Crescita award?
The Sole 24 Ore Leader della Crescita award is an annual ranking that identifies the Italian companies with the highest compound annual revenue growth rate over a three-year period. It is considered one of the most authoritative recognitions in the Italian business landscape. In 2026 the group in this case ranked first in the food category with a +218.94% compound annual growth rate over the three years.
What is an integrated food retail system?
An integrated food retail system brings the customer touchpoints (physical stores, e-commerce, app, loyalty programme, customer service) into a single technological and operational architecture. It lets you understand where customers come from, speak to the same customer on every channel and dose the marketing budget store by store.
What is tiered loyalty?
The tiered loyalty programme is built on rising spend levels (bronze/silver/gold) with benefits that grow and rules for keeping your level. It works far better than a points card because it creates a goal to reach, rewards those who come back often and splits customers by value and frequency. In the case described it generated 47% of total revenue.
How do you tell where the customers of a multi-store food group come from?
Five sources are combined: the tracking codes across the various online channels, the loyalty card that follows the customer everywhere, short surveys after purchase, statistical models that weigh every step, and till data split by group. The challenge is connecting the digital world to the purchase made in store.
How much does a fast-growing food group invest in marketing?
For a fast-growing food group, the marketing budget usually runs from 6% to 12% of revenue. The split varies: 40-55% online paid advertising, 15-25% in-store marketing, 10-20% loyalty programme and customer management, 10-15% content and press office. In the case described, about 8% of revenue.
How long does it take to build an integrated system?
Building an integrated system for a food group with many stores usually takes 6-12 months for the foundation (single customer record, automated messages, purchase journey map, loyalty programme engine), then another 12-18 months to refine and collect data before speaking to each customer in a tailored way.


